Page One

A group of Berkeley High School students held a sparsely attended, but spirited anti-war rally Wednesday in the fading afternoon light of Civic Center Park. They had been denied permission two weeks earlier to hold such an event inside the high school grounds, across the street. 

As part of the demonstration, sophomore Mollie Dutton Starbuck read a letter addressed to “Resident Bush.” 

“The terrorists want holy war, and that is what you want to give them,” she said. “Holy war, an oxymoron from the oxiest of morons: You.”  

Members of Students Halt Revenge and War Under Bush, or SHRUB – a play on one of the President’s nicknames – read poems and played electric guitars and local elected officials spoke. Students took turns reading famous quotes from Ghandi, Martin Luther King, Khalil Gibran and other thinkers and peace advocates. 

Clutching a written statement, junior Jessica Malachowski chided those who think they can’t make a difference. 

“I’ll tell you what you can do,” she said. “You can raise your voice against this war. Your silence means the death of innocent people. How would you like to be the one who pulled the trigger on those homeless children and oppressed women?” 

She lowered her notes to her side. “Do you still think your voice can’t do anything?” she said. “Want to know who said this? I did.” 

Alfonso Alamar, a junior, read Rep. Barbara Lee’s., D–Oakland, speech to the House of Representatives defending her vote against giving the administration broad war powers, and Diane Douglas, the lead organizer of the rally, read a scathing open letter to Bush from TV and film director Michael Moore. 

“Don’t sink to these mass murders’ levels,” the letter said, among other, less polite instructions. 

Three leaders of SHRUB – Douglas, Sarah Price, and Mollie Dutton Starbuck – are also members of a rock band, “Corrupting the Masses.” Taking up their purple instruments, drums and amps, they played anti-war songs written by Douglas: “Feed the Fire” and “Dollar Bill.” 

Non-students also addressed the small gathering. Steve Philandrinos from Global Exchange, the San Francisco-based human rights and cultural exchange organization, called on Americans to “be consistent in their values” by mourning for “hundreds of thousands of dead in Palestine, Iraq, Afghanistan, and Sudan,” the blame for which he placed at the doorstep of the U.S. government. 

“They must also demand justice for victims of U.S. crimes,” Philandrinos said. “Can we train military governments in terrorism and then ask why we are victims of terrorism?” 

Holding a large national flag on a pole, School Board President Terry Doran urged students to “take back this flag from false patriots who drive around in their cars and SUVs and claim it represents lockstep adherence” to the administration’s war agenda. He encouraged them to “make this flag a symbol of our right to be here today,” rather than one of war, and to say the Pledge of Allegiance with different wording if that better reflected their own patriotism. 

City Councilmember Kriss Worthington spoke briefly about the resolution the council passed Tuesday night, which called for a halt to the bombing of Afghanistan. He thanked the students for “getting an early start on being outstanding citizens of Berkeley.” 

In spite of warm, breezy sunshine, the crowd was thin. Only about 20 people, mostly adults, sat on the grass within 50 feet of the stage, which was at the edge of the central fountain plaza. Further back, scattered clumps of students played hack-sack or stood together talking. Not everyone agreed with the rally’s message. 

“I’m a radical liberal and I’m for the war,” said Nicholas Easterday, also a junior. “No one is giving a constructive solution to what we should do. Until they do that, I still support what we do. I think it’s kind of a reactionary liberal response to spew rhetoric and not offer a solution.” 

“I think it’s sad they didn’t get a bigger student turnout,” said Andrew Gruen, a junior. “It’s sad how apathetic students are.” 

“I think there were less people in the park than normal today,” said junior James Foley. 

“We usually go to the UC (demonstrations), said Gruen. “This is kind of new to see, organized by a couple of girls that go to the school.” 

Tim Condit, 63, a self-described lifelong Berkeley resident, Marine Corps veteran and witness to Vietnam-era protests, said today’s educational and media climate discouraged debate and involvement. 

“People were more used to discussing politics back then,” he said. “It makes it harder for these people to organize because their peers don’t want to talk about anything. They’re thinking: ‘Will we be tested on this?’” 

The rally ended after an hour with Douglas playing “Imagine” by John Lennon on her electric guitar. Behind her, on the stone edge of the fountain, Alamar, who read Barbara Lee’s statement, and Jaana Humlie, a senior who read an original poem, swayed together and looked off at the waning sun.