George W. Bush and Al Gore marshaled their legal forces Sunday for a climactic state Supreme Court showdown, with GOP lawyers saying it would be unjust “to keep the state and the nation on hold” during interminable recounts. Democrats said the truth can’t be rushed, as jangled nerves and protests punctuated another painstaking day of south Florida vote-counting.
With the long-count election stretching into a third agonizing week, the court strategy of both camps reached critical mass: Republicans hope to stop manual recounts that threaten Bush’s 930-vote lead out of 6 million cast; Gore wants the work to grind away, under rules most favorable to Democrats.
The candidates kept a low profile as their lawyers prepared for a momentous two-hour court hearing Monday. Each went for a jog and to church.
Calling these “extraordinary times,” Bush’s lawyers argued in court papers that Republican Secretary of State Katherine Harris has the authority to certify election results without accepting hand counts. They also said allowing the recounts to continue in selected Democratic-leaning counties would violate the constitutional rights of voters elsewhere.
“The selective manual recounts authorize county boards to engage in arbitrary and unequal counting of votes, and result in the disparate treatment of Florida voters based solely on where within the state they happen to reside,” Bush argued.
In a separate brief, Harris tried to distance herself from both Bush and Gore, even as Democrats pointed to her GOP presidential campaigning as a sign of bias. All seven supreme court justices were appointed by Democratic governors.
“It is clear, that for the Democrats and the Republicans, the object is to win, and that is understandable,” Harris’ brief said. “The stakes are very high.”
In its paper reply, the Gore team asked the court to set a generous standard for officials to “ascertain the electorate’s will” when they punched ballots in the disputed presidential election. They said local election officials in close cases can “determine the voter’s intent.”
Twelve days after America voted, the weekend tally of overseas absentee ballots lengthened Bush’s tiny 300-vote lead to a still-minuscule 930.
With recounts under way in two Democratic-leaning counties and third set to begin, Gore had a net gain of 76 votes, which if allowed would cut Bush’s lead to 854.
Gore narrowly won the national popular vote and holds a slight edge over Bush in the all-important Electoral College tally, though neither man can reach the required total of 270 electoral votes without Florida’s 25.
The Texas governor spent the day with his family in Austin, Texas. In church, the pastor said, “We continue our prayers for the political process in this country and for those most closely governors by it. May your patience be their patience.”
Gore canceled plans to attend a long-scheduled conference in Tennessee, the home state that deserted him for Bush on Election Day. About 100 pro-Bush protesters packed the sidewalks across from his official residence in Washington. “We want Bush!” they shouted.
The identity of America’s 43rd president rests with the courts and in the ballot-counting rooms of Palm Beach, Broward and Miami-Dade counties, where more than 1.5 million ballots were cast, a majority from Democrats.
“It seems to be that they’re doing everything they can to stop the recounting of votes because they’re slightly ahead and they fear that after the recounting they won’t be,” said Democratic vice presidential candidate Joseph Lieberman, who conducted a rare tour of all five major news shows Sunday.
Bush’s camp continued its assault on the Gore-backed recounts, depicting the process as riddled with human error and Democratic bias. “God only knows how many ballots have been altered,” Gov. Marc Racicot said on “Fox News Sunday.” He called the nation’s political standoff “a very tangled web.”
Gore’s advisers were frustrated Sunday by small recount gains, particularly in Palm Beach County, where the election tempest first began when Democratic voters complained of a confusing ballot.
The vice president’s team accused the local elections board of imposing a too-strict standard for approving ballots.
In one Palm Beach precinct, Democrats said Gore picked up 11 votes in a sample recount conducted more than a week ago. When the same precinct was counted Saturday, Gore had lost 10 votes from the first tally. The board had actually counted 202 precincts, but only released totals where there were no disputed ballots.
In Broward County, Gore’s count by midday Sunday showed a net gain more than 80. More than half the 609 precincts remain to be counted.
Republicans accused the elections board of bowing to political pressure and reversing a decision to throw out ballots that did not have two corners poked out of the “chad” — the tiny pieces of paper in a punch-card ballot.
“The Gore campaign now wants to lower the bar because it needs more votes,” said Ed Pozzuoli, chairman of the county GOP.