Public Comment

< I am writing to express my deep concerns regarding the reporting and editorial practices surrounding the December 28 article, "Screams Without Words," which detailed allegations of widespread sexual violence by members of Hamas on October 7. This piece has significant implications, especially given its utilization by Israeli leaders and Western allies to justify a military campaign in Gaza. 

More than 60 journalism professors across the United States have echoed these concerns, calling for an independent review of how the story was reported, written, and published. Their concerns are not isolated, as numerous other media outlets have similarly critiqued the veracity and sourcing of the report. 

It is particularly troubling that the freelance journalist chiefly involved had previously expressed biased views on social media, which fundamentally undermines the journalistic impartiality required for such a sensitive subject. This issue is compounded by internal discrepancies within The New York Times itself, as highlighted by subsequent reporting from your outlet that contradicts key elements of the original article. 

Journalism’s core should be integrity and accountability. Therefore, I urge The New York Times to heed the call from the academic community for an independent investigation into this matter. Ensuring transparency and accuracy in reporting is crucial, especially when the stakes involve human lives and international relations. 

Furthermore, the broader implications of how such narratives could potentially dehumanize and escalate conflicts should not be overlooked. As readers and global citizens, we rely on institutions like yours to deliver not only news but also ethical journalism. It is extremely troubling that President Biden and several members of Congress repeated these Israeli propaganda talking points to justify the shipment of U.S. weapons to Israel, causing the death and injuries of tens of thousands of Palestinians. I look forward to your response and a resolution that upholds the highest journalistic standards.